Blog › ASN customer denied refund of €33,500 after bank helpdesk fraud
ASN customer denied refund of €33,500 after bank helpdesk fraud
Published
An ASN customer lost €33,500 to bank helpdesk fraud and gets nothing back, the Kifid has ruled. Here is how the scam works and what to do about it.
A customer of the Dutch bank ASN who fell victim to bank helpdesk fraud will not get the loss of more than €33,000 refunded. That is the ruling of the Kifid, the Dutch financial complaints institute that handles disputes between customers and financial firms. The customer was phoned by someone posing as an employee of the fraud desk at "de Volksbank" (ASN's parent bank). In the end he transferred €33,500 to two foreign accounts.
The ruling shows what can happen when you let the fraudster watch your screen and make the payments yourself. This is an important lesson for businesses too. On a business account as well, the way the money leaves the account often decides whether you get it back.
What happened
Earlier this year, an ASN customer received a call from a fraudster. The caller posed as an employee of the fraud desk at "de Volksbank" and said suspicious transactions had been detected on the bank account.
At the fraudster's request, the customer installed AnyDesk, a remote access program. This gave the fraudster remote access to the customer's computer. The customer also installed the Deblock app, which combines a current account with a crypto wallet.
In total, the customer transferred €33,500. The money went to a Belgian bank account and to a French account at Deblock.
When the customer realised he had been scammed, he asked ASN to refund the loss. The bank refused. The customer then took his case to the Kifid.
ASN put forward two arguments:
- The customer does not qualify for the goodwill scheme for victims of bank helpdesk fraud. The money did not go to a "safe account" at his own bank, but to two foreign accounts.
- At the fraudster's request, the customer installed AnyDesk, which gave the fraudster access to his computer.
The Kifid sided with the bank. It points out that the customer made the payments himself and gave the fraudster access to his computer. According to the Kifid, the payments legally count as authorised payment transactions. It has not been established that ASN breached its duty of care. The Kifid also finds that the refusal to grant a refund under the goodwill scheme is not unacceptable by the standards of reasonableness and fairness. The customer's claim has been rejected.
How the scam works
Bank helpdesk fraud relies on trust and time pressure. The set-up is almost always the same.
- The phone call. Someone who says they work in your bank's fraud department calls you. They mention a familiar bank name and say they have seen suspicious transactions. That sounds serious, because you are being warned about fraud.
- The threat. According to the caller, your money is at risk. You must cooperate now to protect it. People who think they are preventing a disaster ask fewer questions.
- The remote access. The caller asks you to install a program, in this case AnyDesk. With it, they can watch your screen and control your computer. They present this as helpful support in "securing" your account.
- The new app or account. In this case, the customer also had to install Deblock. The fraudster has you open an account or wallet they can get into, or sends you to an account they control.
- The transfer. You are told to move your money to a "safe account". That is a lie. The money goes to accounts held by the fraudster and is quickly passed on.
A sensible person falls for this because everything matches what they expect. Banks do warn about fraud. The caller sounds professional, sometimes knows your name, and speaks calmly and with confidence. On top of that comes the fear of losing money. Under that pressure, you follow instructions you would never follow on a quiet day.
What it means for businesses
This news is about a private customer, but the same approach can hit an organisation. Think of a finance employee who gets a call from someone posing as the bank. Or a business owner who prepares the payment orders personally.
What can go wrong:
- Money that is gone. The ruling shows that a bank does not refund automatically. If you make the payments yourself, they count legally as authorised payments. A business can then be left with the loss.
- Access to your systems. With a remote access program, the fraudster sees what is on the screen. That could be banking details, but also emails, customer lists or other company information.
- Work grinding to a halt. A computer that has to be examined and cleaned is out of action for a while. Accounts have to be blocked and new access has to be set up.
- Trust. If a business pays a fraudster by mistake, suppliers and customers notice. It is also hard on the colleague who made the payment.
The case also shows how hard it is to prove your own good faith afterwards. Prevention is far cheaper than trying to get the money back.
How to recognise it
Watch for these signs when "the bank" calls:
- The caller contacts you unprompted and says suspicious transactions have been detected.
- You are asked to act immediately, "or your money will be gone".
- You must install software such as AnyDesk so the caller can watch or take control. A real bank employee does not ask for that.
- You must download an extra app or open a new account or wallet, as with Deblock in this case.
- You must transfer money to a "safe account", especially if that account is not at your own bank or is abroad.
- The caller wants you to stay on the line and not involve colleagues or anyone else.
Any one of these signs is reason enough to hang up.
What you can do
For employees
- Hang up if someone claims to be from the bank and asks you to install software or transfer money.
- Then call the bank yourself, using a number you already have, for example from your bank card or the official website. Do not call back the number the caller gave you.
- Never install remote access software at a caller's request. If you already have, disconnect from the internet and tell your IT administrator or IT service provider straight away.
- Do not transfer money to an account you do not know, even if it is called "safe".
- Report suspected fraud to the bank immediately, even if you are unsure. The sooner the bank knows, the better the chance that a payment can still be stopped.
For the organisation
- Agree that your bank will never phone to ask you to install software or move money. Put this in a short work instruction.
- Limit who can install software. Without admin rights, an employee cannot simply install AnyDesk.
- Have payments above a set amount approved by two people.
- Make sure employees know who to call when in doubt, and that they can report that doubt without embarrassment.
- Set limits for payments made through online banking and record the number of the bank helpdesk where everyone can find it.
- Discuss incidents openly. Someone who reports a mistake without feeling guilty helps the rest of the team.
How Lumyo Awareness helps
At Lumyo Awareness, we imitate attacks like this in a phishing simulation, so your employees meet the trick for the first time in a safe setting. In an awareness training, they then learn to recognise the signs, such as a caller who wants software installed, and know exactly what to do. IT service providers and MSPs can resell Lumyo as a partner or manage it for their clients.